…but I know what I like.

Posted by resonanteye on 04/13/2013

I found this little list of ways to criticize art. It’s interesting that not until four steps in, the final step, does the list include

  • 4. Judgment- What do I think of the work?

In fact, your personal opinion of a piece of art is the last thing to consider.

working on a nudeThis is a good thing, and a bad thing. I mean, every piece of art is trying to communicate, to get across something- to YOU. You are the viewer, and what you think of the work outside of all formal critique, is really the most important thing. Really. You don’t have to know the elements of design or the formalities of color theory to know what you like.

You either like it, or you don’t. Maybe learning more changes your mind, maybe it doesn’t. But your initial response to a piece, without any external or additional information, is really the meaningful part of a critique like this.

I said it’s a good thing, too, didn’t I? That’s because if you don’t know why you like it or hate it, you can’t explain that to anyone else- most importantly, the artist who’s asking for your response.

Learning the terms for different techniques and processes can help with this, but just knowing basics, such as he gives at the end of this list, go a long way. You definitely don’t need to go to class to learn these things. Fuck, I’m an uneducated/self-taught artist; I think you can learn these things, and how to express them, just fine, by reading online, by looking at art, and taking the time to think about your opinions.

I don’t know much, but I know what I like. And if I tell someone how I feel about something they’ve made I like to try to tell them why I feel that way. A negative opinion expressed by a great critic is the most helpful thing on earth.

5 Responses to “…but I know what I like.”

  1. stacqui said

    Nothing is worse than when you show someone your art (or writing in my case!), and they say something doesn’t work, but can’t tell you what that something is! Or vaguely say they like it, but not elaborate.

    Like

    • yes, I really like specifics, more than anything. although sometimes, hearing that the mood is off, or the colors seem “too much”, helps me. it’s a fine line between helpful and meaningless but I always assume people are trying their best to help me out by even speaking up!

      Like

  2. I generally stay quiet when something doesn’t look quite right to me, would you prefer it if I spoke up?

    Like

SPEAK UP, leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: